Template
Competency-Based Performance Review Template
Global HR

Get the resource for free
What is a competency-based performance review?
A competency-based performance review evaluates an employee's performance against the specific skills and behaviors that are essential to their role and to the organization's success. Instead of judging results alone, it looks at how the employee works, using defined competencies and expected levels of mastery.
Deel's competency-based performance review template is a free form for running this kind of review. It covers core competencies, technical competencies, and leadership potential, and links the results to goals and a development plan for the next review period.
Key takeaways
A competency-based review makes evaluations more consistent and fair, because every reviewer assesses the same defined behaviors rather than general impressions.
Competencies only work in a review when they're observable. DDI recommends replacing broad skills like "communication" with specific behaviors like "adjusts messages to the audience."
Engage in Deel HR links competency frameworks to performance reviews with one click, and shows each competency's definition next to the review form, so reviewers have context as they rate.
What's in the competency-based performance review template?
The competency-based performance review template has 11 sections, running from employee details and reviewer instructions through competency ratings to goals, a development plan, and a follow-up timeline.
| Section | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Employee details and rating scale | Employee name, role, department, manager, review period, and the rating scale (if used) |
| Instructions for the reviewer | Guidelines for running the review consistently and fairly |
| Evaluation questions | Rating and open-ended questions on performance and competency mastery |
| Core competencies | The competencies every role needs (listed in the next section) |
| Technical competencies | The specific technical skills the employee's current role requires |
| Leadership potential | The employee's leadership skills and readiness for greater responsibility |
| Overall performance summary | A holistic view of performance across all areas |
| Areas for improvement | Where the employee can strengthen their skills and contributions |
| Goals for the next review period | Specific, measurable objectives to reach before the next review |
| Development planning | Concrete next steps such as training, mentoring, and other growth opportunities |
| Follow-up timeline | Scheduled check-ins to review progress and adjust goals |
Which competencies does the template assess?
The template assesses six core competencies, plus technical competencies and leadership potential that you tailor to each role. The table shows each core competency with an example question.
| Competency | What it assesses | Example question |
|---|---|---|
| Communication | How clearly the employee shares information with colleagues and stakeholders | On a scale of 1–5, how effectively has the employee communicated with internal and external stakeholders? (from the template) |
| Teamwork | How the employee collaborates and contributes to team results | How effectively has the employee supported and contributed to the team's overall performance? (from the template) |
| Time management and prioritization | How well the employee plans work and meets deadlines | Describe a time the employee reprioritized work to meet a changing deadline. |
| Problem-solving and analytical thinking | How the employee approaches complex issues and uses data | Give an example of a problem the employee solved and the approach they took. |
| Self-development | How actively the employee builds new skills | What new skills has the employee developed this period, and how? |
| Growth mindset | How the employee responds to feedback and change | How does the employee respond to constructive feedback? Give a recent example. |
Questions marked "from the template" appear in the downloadable template. The others are examples you can adapt. The template also includes an adaptability question: "Can you provide an example of a time when the employee quickly adapted to new technology or software?"
To choose technical competencies and set mastery levels for each role, use the competency framework template, which includes 140+ core, functional, and technical competencies.
How do you use a competency-based performance review template?
Use a competency-based performance review template by first matching its competencies to the role, then rating each one against a defined level of mastery, backed by examples.
Check that the competencies in the template match the role's expectations and your organization's goals.
Add or remove competencies for the employee's specific role or department.
Use your organization's full competency framework to select the right competencies.
Decide whether to use rating scales or keep the review qualitative, and adjust the scales to your needs.
Make sure each review criterion is clear, measurable, and relevant to the role's performance expectations.
Fill in the expected level of mastery for each competency on the evaluation form.
Give specific examples of where the employee exceeds or only just meets expectations, and where they can improve.
Balance constructive feedback with positive feedback.
Who is the competency-based performance review template for?
The template is for teams that want reviews based on clear, role-specific expectations:
HR teams introducing or standardizing competency-based reviews
People managers who want to give specific, behavior-based feedback
Organizations with a competency framework that want to connect it to performance reviews and development plans
FAQs
Is the competency-based performance review template free?
Yes. The competency-based performance review template is free to download, and you can edit its competencies, questions, and rating scales to fit your organization.
What is the competency model of performance review?
The competency model of performance review evaluates an individual's performance against a predefined set of competencies that are critical for success in their role. These competencies usually align with the organization's core values, goals, and job requirements.
What is the typical competency assessment process?
A typical competency assessment identifies the competencies a role needs, defines performance expectations, assesses the employee against each competency, then gives feedback and builds a development plan. The steps are:
Identify relevant competencies from the job description and scope.
Define performance expectations for each competency.
Choose assessment methods, such as self-assessment, input from coworkers, or evaluation against pre-set metrics.
Evaluate performance against each competency.
Give feedback to the employee.
Create a professional development plan to address areas for improvement.
What is a competency framework for performance management?
A competency framework for performance management is a structured way to define, assess, and develop competencies across an organization. It sets out the skills and behaviors each role needs, so they can be used to evaluate performance, set goals for the next period, and support development and career progression.
What are common competency-based questions?
Common competency-based questions ask about a person's abilities, behaviors, and experiences related to a specific competency. They combine rating questions, such as "On a scale of 1–5, how effectively has the employee communicated with internal and external stakeholders?", with open questions that ask for examples. See the competency table above for more.
How do you write a competency review?
Write a competency review by rating the employee's proficiency in each competency the role requires, then backing each rating with specific examples of their behavior. Include areas of strength and areas for improvement, keep the review structured and objective, and end with actionable feedback that motivates the employee to keep developing.
More resources
Competency framework template (140+ core, functional, and technical competencies)